Thanks very much again to Paul for this next instalment of his wonderful guest post series.
You can find all of the 'Filohax' posts here. There is an index of all the previous filohax posts here.
Spine-less is more
Dominique made an interesting comment recently about Filofax without logos on the spine.
Line up left to right: Winchester Croc 7/8, Winchester 7/8, Winchester 7/8, Gloucester 7/8, Grosvenor 7/8
I'm from the twentieth century, and her comment reminded me of a peculiar British trait that I think was superseded when the 'Americanisation' of British culture really accelerated in the 1980's - 'unostentatiousness'. The 'no logo' spined Filofax were a product of an era when a product signalled its worth by its quality, not by marketing.
I think it's why the mark 'made in England' was kept on the inside cover- it wasn't done to 'show off'!
However the British have also always had a strong paradoxical streak - who could ever say our flag was unostentatious?!!


I’ve heard it said that the addition of the f on the spine was an attempt to make a clearer, visual distinction between the Filofax brand and the rapidly growing competition at that time. This does seem plausible. An oval surround was also added later to increase the prominence.
ReplyDeleteAbsolutely right. The world was awash with cheap, generic organisers in the very late 1980s. The finances at Filofax were collapsing as people would not (and didn’t need to) pay high prices for a Filofax organiser that externally looked almost identical to an unbranded one. The “F” helped to distinguish the brand and make it appear more exclusive. I don’t recall anything subtle about it - reviving sales (and subsequently, in the early 90s, decimating costs by moving manufacture to China) was everything!
ReplyDeleteI was wondering when the 'rise of the logo' occurred. The closest I could find around a discussion of that, with a cursory search was this article about the more recent decline of the logo...
ReplyDeletehttps://sociallifemagazine.com/luxury-lifestyle/decline-of-logo-rise-of-experience/
At least it acknowledged the 'messaging' that logos had provided.
Kevin, et al
ReplyDeleteInteresting article on logo/experience - thanks for the link, if nothing else for its voice. It was so armored with snobbery it almost ran me over.
This: 'They evaluate whether a brand inhabits their world authentically or merely purchases access to it. The judgment is more sophisticated and harder to manipulate.'
Illuminating especially on how a brand is perceived as of diminishing value - for those with sophistication - once those others with 'aspirational purchases' (read as: buying commodities above their station) try and buy into a higher social stratum by grabbing the entry level option that still carries the logo that signals they've reached the bottom rung of the exalted. This highlights one of the key ideas of brand marketing; the visible logo as both key (into previously locked rooms) and sign (that you're now there.) Reminds me of the famous scene from the movie 'American Psycho' where the Wall Street guys all get a semi-erotic charge from each other's beautifully presented business cards, perceiving a hierarchy of signs, when they all have essentially the same job. But for all that, I remember the value to one's Yuppiedom to have a Filofax (as opposed to nothing) and then a clearly identified Filofax when the very name Filofax had become used generically, like Hoover of the previous generation.
As for the placement of the identifiers on the inside cover I always thought it was both an acknowledgment that one of beauties of the 1980s Winchesters was their elegant simplicity that worked best when one could just run one's thumb over the unadorned front cover while holding it with casual security, standing on the platform and scanning the Financial Times while waiting for the 8:40 to St. Paul's, and also the British's early mastery of the Humblebrag. Brag, but do it quietly, and with subtlety.
The tend towards the experience rather than the logo is another subtle signaling switch, when the general citizenry can too easily purchase the brand's visible, tactile identifier there becomes a need to created a further elevated stratum, a knowledge, almost a new sense of being, that those who 'inhabit the world authentically', as the article put it (as opposed to those who just have the gizmo with the logo) don't have - is sold as 'the experience.'
I think of John Lennon's quote (essentially about signs) at the Royal Variety Concert in 1963:
"For our last number, I'd like to ask your help. Will the people in the cheaper seats clap your hands? And for the rest of you, if you'll just rattle your jewelry..."
James G